Okay that went totally in the opposite direction i expected
HAHAHA aww well A for effort.
That'll learn her, Puget Sean!
either he has massive ADD, or he is teaching her… something
why can't it be both?
also, The Game.
ah dick! i wasnt prepared for that at all!
thanks, now i lost.
it's ALL TRUE.
i just got the TETRIS! Sadly, I was already ball$-deep into computers at that point and didn't do much writing on paper. I was hoping that computers would advance quickly enough to help my cartooning. Maybe that's why I got out of cartooning for 15 years! As always, excellent work Meredith! I like the subtlety that your strips contain and the emotional "subtext" (a word I hated in college and much as "ergo").
I hope the new year is being kind to you!
BTW, when i say "by that point", I am refering to late '80's/early '90's. I was already a computer nerd by the time Tetris came out! If I could go back to that time and do anything different, I'd probably still waste my life and skills! Let's here it for low self esteem!
He got mad because Hannah was complaining about her realized potential? Anyone got any other interpretations? That doesnt feel quite right.
no, Meredith is trying to give the impression that he's determined to set things right and tell off that CatPoopCookies dude, but then Sean disappoints us by playing Tetris instead 😛
I think it's a little more complex then that. Hanna pretty much spent all of two strips ago saying how she's tolerating him, that it's white guilt (or something…) and to pretty much sit down and shut up while the grownups talk.
Last strip, she finds out that people really like her favorite recipe… after it's been passed through the alimentary canal of a cat.
This strip, depressed(?) from her findings, she tells Sean that she appreciates his ideas, then in the same breath describes it as 'scribbles in a book' and from 'simpler times'.
Frankly, I know my ideas are shit, but even I'd give her the finger and stomp off by then. Comparisons to Sean's ideas (a bit vague on what he is doing in the moleskine. Drawing? Writing? Pressing flowers?) and Hanna's cookies could be made.
Yeah, i agree, sh's basically saying his ideas are crap enough to be pipe dreams, although she doesn't really mean it to insult him, she's actually just having a super-selfish moment and just knocking him in passing.
Also two comics ago, it was mentioned that if it wasn't "a mandated holiday" he'd be "playing Nintendo right now", so I figure he just got sick of trying to support his assholish friend and ditched her.
Hmmm… I didn't think she was looking at Sean's art but some of her own doodles, since it was her sketchbook that she loaned him. I think I was projecting a little too much of myself though and somehow thought that Hannah also drew in addition to baking. I didn't see the obvious dig on Sean here. Ugh, I feel like a turd now.
No, no! I'm with you and Secretly Superhero; I can't see anything in the comic that invalidates this reading of it. Sean is inspired by a flash of heroism that pretty much pans out by the time he's done exerting himself in crappy weather.
The link with to him doing Tetris and what Hannah says a few comics back is down to the succinctness of Hannah's judgement: without some kind of extraordinary mandate or excitement, Puget Sean's revert-to-type default behaviour really is just playing Nintendo (as is mine!).
I do like that there are lots of (equally valid!) interpretations flying around, though. A welcomely confusing installment!
I don't get it.
Me neither 🙁 I didn't really understand this storyline at all…
Well, that sure worked…
Oh my god… I can totally relate to this. And people would give me weird looks for telling the truth.
REALLY, Puget Sean? Really?
You know, I really appreciate Hannah's honesty in this three part series. We always see her in the strip as this happy-go-lucky kind of girl who's practically invulnerable; it's nice to see that she has the same amount of doubts that others in the strip have. That being said, I totally sympathize with Hannah. It sucks to have to cater your dreams, creativity and ambitions to others. You lose part of yourself I think and I'm pretty sure that's what Hannah is feeling.
Or maybe I'm wrong! Either way, suck it Puget Sean. No amount of Tetris will make your daddy love you.
I was really expecting an out-of-character expression of kindness from Puget Sean. But… I suppose that's too much to ask.
Before now I always kind of wondered why everybody hated Puget Sean, and I even sort of liked him. Or at least sympathized with/pitied him, shoved in a corner to draw his anger away.
But now I see he's just a dick.
I know that Meredith herself expressed Sean's intentions as flimsy and that that's the joke, but when you read the comic itself technically he could have actually set things right and cheered up Hannah in between panels 8 and 9, they're so far apart. Just a little comic theory. It might just be the desperately good part of me that wants happy endings, ha.
I took it as a two-fold thing – 1st: Meredith may be commenting thru Hannah about her 2nd commercial book deal disappintment and possibly having to return to the job market (we're bummed too). 2nd: I also took it (as stated above) that the only time that when everything WAS a possiblity, as Hannah said, was when when we were kids. So Puget Sean is playing Tetris as a way to get those Glory Daze. I kinda do that thru listening to 80's music. Back when I had no money, no car, and high school really sucked. Now life sucks, but i own it, and I can do what i want (sic!).
I'd like to hear Meredith's opinion.
I'm fascinated by all these different takes on this. People 'siding' with different people here.
Important note: While some comics (books, art, etc.) have specific people correlate to specific characters, ultimately they all are the author. Being so ('ergo', just to needle ya…) all the characters are Meredith. So she could be Sean being told to sit in the corner and be quiet. She could be Hanna being told that her hard work and effort is cat crap. And she could be Sean stomping off to go play Tetris.
This method of interpretation is basically how I got through high school English.
It can be a challenging technique, venting your conflicts and frustration into a writing or drawing piece. I never actually thought about Octopus Pie being extensions of Meredith… You know, some comics make/made it obvious, like KC Green's Horribleville (and sometimes Gunshow), and I'm sure a large portion of XKCD.
That being said, inserting authors' lives into their work is precisely how I'm getting through high school english.
EDIT: Challeging technique *without making it obvious or pressing people for laughs, i.e. misunderstood cartoonist's schtick*.
I don't totally agree with characters being versions of the artist -except in this case. Many times they are based on other people (firends/family/enemies/celebs, etc) that the artis likes or whould make a good blend. You need both conflict and harmony to make a balanced strip. But, in most characters could be found a PART of the artist.
As an artist turned burnt-out social gaming illustrator, I feel you, Hannah. Oh, I feel you.
Maybe Puget Sean simply feels empathy for Alexey Pajitnov, who created Tetris but had the rights to his creation yanked out from under him by the Soviet government.
Procrastination, I understand its addiction too Sean 🙁 (It looks like that sort of thing to me anyway).
I am real good at Tetris.
I have nothing else to say, though. 🙁
Fuck, I would have done the same thing. That's whatchu get!
Seems to me that this goes back to supporting Eve's notions about Hannah's group of (everybody but Marek/Marigold) stoner buddies. Hannah had best let go of a lot of stuff – hmmm – just like Eve. Her success (on many levels) depends on that.
Tres subtil, Mlle Gran.
I sometimes my life was a comic that people could overanalyze and give advice on!
Hannah is still a horrible bitch with control issues who's not happy if she's not in charge, bossing everyone around and generally being an unlikeable shithead.
Disagree 75%, Playing Return to Castle Wolfenstein 25% (well, it's got better graphics than Tetris – it's even got a story!).
Whee, no one else has the same interpretation I had!
When Puget Sean says "Wait here!" he turns everything back into a possibility for Hannah. As long as she's waiting, it could be *anything*.
Then he goes and plays Tetris, because he doesn't want to resolve that feeling and take it away from her.
I think he's not only just being a dick and tricking her into waiting there for a while, but that he's also been inspired by her comment about everything once being full of possibility to go recapture that feeling by playing Tetris. He may even want to go back and tell her how it made him feel (doubtful, but funny.) So it's revenge AND solipsism he's manifesting.
Dammit Puget Sean. You idiot, you nearly did something.
I don't understand Sean's intentions here (and realistically, someone doing something this strange usually doesn't understand their own intentions very well), but that was the funniest moment I have read in a long, long time. Excellent, excellent subversion of a serious moment!
I looked back at the past page and I just saw "Fuck my life" and drawings of fire on the other book page in the last panel.
That was Puget Sean who wrote that, right? Oh man. Seeing that helped explain a lot about why Sean reacted like that.
Sean's face… I just love the expressions he makes. I thought he would actually do something productive or helpful, only to storm off and play Tetris on his NES.
Of course, there's Hanna's little bit, "Y'know, no one ever cares as much about your ideas…" I think it's more inward than an insult to Puget Sean.
By the way, whatever happened to the BACK button? It seems to lead to a non-existing page.
The punch line doesn't seem ambiguous to me. Hana's complaining about her too-much-success problems after consistently putting Sean down. What was supposed to happen?
I thought Puget Sean had good intentions but just got distracted by Tetris. It's like trying to get work done in front of the TV.
guys guys i have a radically innovative interpretation of the major themes and message of this strip, i contend that meredith made a funny joke and then drew it, the end!
This story arc threw me off guard because it was so short. Other than that, I love Hanna's quote here. It is priceless.
I know right? I expected wacky hijinks of harvesting Manuel's poo for weeks to come. This is a suitable ending, though.
U mad, Sean? U Mad?
Yeah, he mad.
I don't blame him, though. Besides, Tetris is awesome.
Wow I can't believe how strong the Hannah hate is on this one. I don't even think she did anything wrong this time — pretty sure when she said "No one thinks your ideas are as good as you do" she was talking about herself and her own sketches.
That's what she WANTED to say. Given the context, however…
I swear I left a comment RIGHT HERE a couple of days ago.
I don't really care "How" the joke was supposed to be funny or all the different stories and take speople are putting on this strip.
I laughed because I saw that his hair is longer than mine.
This comic is almost a response to my earlier comment about how I don't like Puget Sean.
Because now I love him.
Interesting to note the two main strains of interpretation here seem to hinge on two gendered perspectives:
Ladies are disappointed that Sean failed to be "heroic" and ended up playing tetris.
Dudes feel that Sean is offended by implicit criticism, and plays tetris as self-medication.
This says a lot about our own (heteronormative) romances, doesn't it?
Y'know… maybe I'm just tired but what if, since she's saying that she misses the days when everything was a possibility, his going home and leaving her alone was his way of setting her up for something and then leaving it as a possibility? I dunno. Like I said, tired.
I think when Hannah sees whats written in the notebook what he did will become much clearer. If I could venture a guess it is probably something rather rude that he kind of felt a little bad as she reflected, having been humbled, but not bad enough to mean what he wrote.
It's a good thing Hannah didn't stand there long waiting for this big revilation.
I'd be pissed.
Comments are closed.